(Video) Sergio Aguero joins ex-Man United duo in elite club after five-goal heroics against Newcastle

Jermain Defoe – TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR 9-1 Wigan Athletic (November 22, 2009)

Defoe is the only one of this special quintet to have scored all five of his goals in the second half. He completed his hat-trick against Wigan in seven minutes, and scored twice more before the whistle.